In recent months, Michael Carrick has taken over as head coach of Manchester United, stepping in for the sacked Ruben Amorim. Carrick's appointment came at a time when the club was under pressure to improve their performance in the Premier League. Following his takeover, Carrick led the team to impressive victories against Manchester City and Arsenal, igniting renewed hopes among supporters that Old Trafford might be experiencing a turnaround in fortunes. His efforts were praised by many, including Sky Sports pundit Roy Keane, who noted that the players seemed to regain their swagger and confidence on the pitch during these matches. Despite the early success Carrick has enjoyed, Keane has been vocal in his stance that he does not feel Carrick is suited for a long-term managerial role at Manchester United. Keane believes that the club requires a manager with a greater pedigree and experience, someone who can rise to the challenges of leading a club of Manchester United's stature. He emphasized that winning a couple of games, even against formidable opponents, should not be the sole basis for determining a manager's capability for significant success. Keane's analysis of the situation indicates a critical viewpoint on Carrick's potential. He expressed skepticism regarding the idea of offering Carrick the position permanently, regardless of how the remainder of the season unfolds. Emphasizing the need for someone 'bigger and better,' Keane pointed out that even if Carrick does manage to secure a top-four finish, it would not convince him that Carrick is the right choice for the role moving forward. Rather, he envisions that a world-class manager, someone like Thomas Tuchel or Carlo Ancelotti, would be more appropriate to lead the squad into a new era of competition for trophies. Additionally, Carrick himself has acknowledged the importance of focusing on the current matches and not getting overconfident about the victories they have achieved thus far. He appreciates the challenge ahead and recognizes that there is still significant work required to build on the progress made recently. Thus, while Carrick's initial results have been promising, the overarching sentiment remains that the long-term direction of Manchester United rests on securing a more experienced manager to prepare the club for future challenges and successes.